Our rationale for sleeping with a dog is that she doesn't eliminate where she sleeps (except for the first night when she "baptized" my leg not once but twice!). Looked at another way, it's a matter of "let me sleep with you or I'll shit on your floor!" This is a very effective form of persuasion, one I should have considered as a desperate and lonely young man.
Sleeps is a euphemism for what happens, really. Maggie alternates between lying near our legs and lying on our about our heads, on our pillows. It must be difficult to choose, because she alternates these positions with some frequency, occasionally using her scratchy back toenails to push off from our foreheads. This is an effective method of propulsion for her, but for us is a problematic interruption of REM sleep. "Let me sit on your head or I'll shit on your floor!"
This morning, Walker came into our room at 5:30 a.m. in order to iron his shirt for work. He was at a party until midnight last night and so did not have time to iron his shirt at a more traditional hour. "Do you mind if I turn on the overhead light so I can see to iron?" he asked thoughtfully. We declined. Maggie suggested that Walker take her outside for her duties (our reward), and Walker thoughtfully declined, suggesting that he was busy ironing. Maggie began barking at him insistently. Walker submitted to the will of the puppy and took her out. "Let me iron shirts in your room at the butt crack of dawn or I will shit on your floor!"
Soon Walker drove off to work, neatly pressed shirt and all. Robyn fell back to sleep. Maggie and I lay around in bed and she eventually came up and gave me many wet licky kisses. Cuteness, softness and cuddliness are evolutionary adaptations which enable dogs to survive their formative years. (How does this explain the survival Chihuahuas and Yorkshire terriers, or those hideous Chinese Crested dogs with no hair except for a stringy mohawk?)
I got up, made coffee and assisted our canines in once again visiting the back yard. I have diverted Maggie from chewing on multiple household items, including me (reduced as I am to the status of household item). After about an hour of this, both dogs are lying peacefully on the floor, convincing imitations of the reality I dreamed I'd inhabit when we added a puppy. Dogs living in harmony, sprawled on the floor in postures of domestic bliss. Soon I'll drive to Iowa City to see a client or two. I will stay awake for a while due to massive doses of caffeine administered orally.
Later I'm coming to YOUR house. "Let me take a nap, or I'll shit on your floor!"